The Worst of Plans Leads to the Worst of Trial Outcomes: Oldham v Arrow Speed Controls Ltd, 2026 BCSC 2238

© Dan Wilband, MA, JD/BCL

He co-founded the company in 1980.

At 72, he was fired. The plan was called Project Brutus.

The employee had spent most of his working life with the business. He co-founded it, sold it to a larger group in 1993, and stayed on as president for the next 3 decades. He never had a written employment contract.

In the fall of 2023, the employer’s executives drafted an internal memo about his future. They called it Project Brutus. It set out their concerns about his conduct and referred to the steps to “a leadership change.”

At the time, he was closing a deal to build control panels for a new mill in Texas, worth more than US$5.5 million.

Ten months after the memo, with that project underway, the employer let him go without cause. There was no warning and no conversation about its concerns. The court found the timing was at least partly about getting the deal done first.

Then the employer went looking for cause. For years, the company had bought enclosures from a business owned by the employee’s son.

The court found nothing improper. The son’s company was the only Canadian distributor of that product, other managers handled the pricing, and the employer had known about the relationship since at least 2016. The evidence also showed the product helped win the Texas deal.

The employer also argued he failed to mitigate when he took an $80,000 job with his son. The court disagreed. At 72, after 44 years, that was a reasonable choice.

That brought the case down to notice.

Courts have long treated 24 months as a rough upper limit. The employer argued that no BC court had ever gone higher.

The court said this was one of the rare cases that justified it: a founder and president, 44 years of service, 72 years old, and no comparable executive roles available. It awarded him 30 months. After deducting his new salary, that came to about $518,000.

The court didn't stop there. It added $50,000 in punitive damages, describing the employer as an “employment archaeologist” digging for grounds to dismiss that didn’t exist, and calling its conduct high-handed and malicious.

It also ordered special costs against the employer for its failed counterclaim against the son and his company.

The 30 months will get headlines. It shows that the old 24-month ceiling can bend a lot for the right employee.

The punitive damages award is also notable and came from something employers can control: how they plan a termination, how they carry it out, and what they do afterward.

Oldham v Arrow Speed Controls Ltd, 2026 BCSC 2238

Next
Next

Another one doesn’t bite the dust: Good news for employers